Avila & Shaddow Attorneys at Law
Call For A Free Consultation
818-676-9658 / 866-450-4LAW
Se Habla Español
Menu Contact
Aggressive Protection of Your Rights Under The Law

Federal court of appeals ruling supports employers

California workers as well as their employers may want to take note of a federal appellate court ruling issued on Jan. 18. It means that employees cannot necessarily use a disability or the Family and Medical Leave Act as excuses in regards to termination for misconduct and work performance. Therefore, in most of these situations, the employer's assessment of the facts will matter more than the employee's theory when it comes to the type of punishment the employee will receive for their misconduct or poor work performance.

The issue began when the plaintiff, who was a customer service representative and who uses insulin for Type I diabetes, was on a last chance agreement because of a past poor work performance incident. During one of her shifts, she reportedly hung up the telephone on her customers at least twice. The plaintiff denied the allegations, claiming she had a diabetes-related low blood sugar incident at the time. However, no other evidence existed to support her assertion, and she failed to report having any medical issues until after she was confronted about additional disciplinary measures or discharge.

Thus, it was concluded that her actions were intentional and deserved discharge. The Tenth Circuit ruled that employers in such instances are not obligated to let an employee's version of the facts, or a previous use of FMLA leave or a simple pre-existing disability, dictate disciplinary measures by an employer because of the employee's poor work performance or misconduct.

By law, employers are not allowed to harass, prohibit or discriminate against any employee who rightfully takes FMLA leave. Those whose employer has denied them leave, or who have experienced discrimination for taking family leave might want to speak with an attorney for direction.

Source: National Law Review, "Employee's 'Alternative Facts" Can't Overcome Summary Judgment for Employer", David Wiley, Jan. 23, 2017

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Avila & Shaddow

We offer an initial consultation at no charge. Please call our office at 818-676-9658 or 866-450-4LAW. You may also contact our attorneys via email using the form below.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Email Us For A Response

Avila & Shaddow Attorneys at Law

Southern California
21800 Oxnard Street
Suite 1180 - Penthouse
Woodland Hills, CA 91367

Phone: 818-676-9658
Fax: 818-337-7265
Map & Directions

  • LACBA Los Angels Country Bar Association
  • Rated By Super Lawyers Mark S. Avila
  • California Employment Lawyers Association
  • Avvo Ratings Excellent Top Attorney Employment Law
  • Consumer Attorneys Association Of Los Angels Sustaining Member
  • AV Preeminent Peer Rated for Highest Level of Professional Excellence