Avila & Shaddow Attorneys at Law
Southern California 866-450-4LAW
San Fernando Valley 818-676-9658
Nationwide Toll Free 866-450-4LAW
E-mail icon Se habla español
Main navigation search

Aggressive Protection of Your Rights Under The Law Schedule a Consultation

The limits of employer rights in California

In the event that an employee says something bad about an employer's product, it would seem logical that the employer could take action. However, the type of action and when that action could be taken has been limited by several court decisions. In a March 2016 case, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit ruled in that two employees of a Jimmy John's franchisee could not be fired for implying that the company's sandwiches were possibly being made by sick employees.

The employees were terminated by the franchisee after posting signs outside of the stores and on bulletin boards. In its ruling, the 8th Circuit said that the signs were not malicious enough considering Jimmy John's strict call off policy. Generally, employees are not allowed to call off due to illness unless they have a replacement. The ruling was based on several NLRB cases that said statements made during labor disputes were protected speech.

As a general rule, statements that have some elements of truth to them are generally protected even if there is no labor dispute per se. Furthermore, statements made about working conditions are more likely to be upheld as protected speech as opposed to statements about the quality of a product. Employers are asked to consider whether speech may be protected before taking action against employees who make disparaging comments about the company.

Employee rights can be both supplied by federal or state law or by legal precedent. People who feel that they have been unfairly treated when they attempt to exercise them, such as through termination or denial of a raise, may want to discuss their situation with an attorney in order to see what remedies they may have.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  1. Peer Review Rated For Ethical Standards & Legal Ability | AV PREEMINENT
  2. Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles
  3. Avvo
  4. LACBA, Los Angeles County Bar Association
  5. Super Lawyers
  6. California Employment Lawyers Association

Need Help? Have Questions? Contact our attorneys for immediate assistance

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Southern California
21800 Oxnard Street
Suite 1180 - Penthouse
Woodland Hills, CA 91367

Toll Free: 866-450-4LAW
Phone: 818-676-9658
Fax: 818-337-7265
Map & Directions